The Olympics captures our imagination. It is built on dreams, wrapped in narrative, fueled by drama, and played on the world’s athletic stage. If we were to draw an analogy to the financial world, the Olympics lines up well with the stock market. It holds the promise of the thrill of victory, and at times delivers the agony of defeat.
Football, on the other hand, demands our attention. It is persistent, visceral, and woven into the fabric of American society. Extending the financial analogy, football is akin to interest rates and the bond market. You might fully engage, casually observe, be perplexed or uninterested, but it’s difficult to completely ignore.
The owners of the thirty two NFL teams set the rules of the game. Similar to the football team owners, the twelve members of the Federal Reserve’s Federal Open Market Committee (FOMC) set interest rate policies that affect the level of interest rates and influence bond returns.
The FOMC is now suggesting that policy may soon shift from ‘hike’ to ‘hold’. If this is the case, short-term interest rates, which are currently at 5.5% and which have been on an upward path since 2021, could stabilize in the near future.
The managers of large bond mutual funds and ETFs function like NFL coaches. They call the shots for their respective funds (teams) and decide which bonds (players) to hold and which to trade.
Several large fund managers have been encouraging financial advisors to add longer-term bonds and bond funds to their clients’ portfolios.
Vanguard, the well-known firm in Pennsylvania, claims “opportunities in bonds abound”, and “now is the time to add high-quality bond exposure.” PIMCO, the California-based bond specialist, proclaims “Bonds are back” and recommends investors “make the most of this compelling opportunity”.
And the world’s largest asset manager, New York based BlackRock says “the Fed should be done” and it’s Chief Investment Officer for Fixed Income says “You can put your shoulder behind a bit more of interest rate (bond) exposure.”
The bond fund managers are making strong statements, with conviction, and backed by experience. But like NFL coaches who are advocates for their teams, these bond fund managers are prone to offer positive prognostications for their funds.
My bias is to proceed with skepticism and caution regarding the “opportunities” offered by intermediate- and long-term bond funds. Why?
- Interest rate cycles tend to unfold over years, rather than weeks or months
- Bond rates are still adjusting from all-time Pandemic-era lows
- Bonds with the shortest maturities, and lowest risk, today offer the highest yields
The picture below, courtesy of JP Morgan Asset Management, is one that I’ve shared with you previously. When thinking about interest rate risk in client portfolios, I keep this image at the forefront of my mind.
The blue line in the chart displays the nominal yield of the 10-year Treasury bond over time. Today’s 10-Year Treasury bond pays just over 4% annually. Although the yield is significantly higher than what was on offer during the early days of the pandemic, it sits well below the long-term average yield of 5.76%.